Sign up FAST! Login

Kelly Clarkson Already Gone and Beyonce Halo are the same song.

Stashed in: Copying, Mashups!, Beyonce!, @kelly_clarkson

To save this post, select a stash from drop-down menu or type in a new one:

Reddit comment:

Classic similar songs as they're both written by Ryan Tedder. As already noted in the YouTube comments, this is just like the Roar + Brave controversy for them being similar.

Still, they use similar, but not identical progressions, at least in the pre-choruses. When the songs are played at the same time some dissonance is present at a couple points.

Here are the chord progressions from HookTheory. Three out of four chords match (the ii and V being different in the second chord of the progression):


Already Gone: