Google Baby Picture -- What the first Google Search Engine web page looked like ...
Adam Rifkin stashed this in History of Tech!
Internet Archive has what Google looked like later in 1998:
Here's a 1998 screenshot:
Here's screenshots of other top websites in 1997:
They all had a Borland Turbo Pascal kind of feel back then. Lots of Times New Roman.
Here's an artistic interpretation of what Google would have looked like in the 1980s:
Only slightly more advanced than if Google Postcard launched earlier:
And here is a visual history of Google's home page, 1997 through 2013:
Compare with "Baby Imgur", a screenshot from 2009:
Internet Archive has:
By comparison, the design of Reddit is pretty much unchanged since 2005: