Sign up FAST! Login

How to Argue About Research You Don't Like: A Flowchart

Stashed in: Conversations, Flowcharts!, Your argument is invalid., Your doing it wrong., Morgan Freeman

To save this post, select a stash from drop-down menu or type in a new one:

Robert T. Gonzalez explains:

Via WaPo's Wonkblog comes the definitive guide to critiquing research findings that rub you the wrong way. And while this chart refers more specifically to studies on things like health and budget policy, it works surprisingly well for scientific studies, as well.

Whether the research was conducted nationally or locally, for example, is not unlike asking whether the test subjects in a psych study were Western, educated, rich, industrialized, rich and democratic (aka WEIRD). The question of whether the research findings generally mesh with those of previous investigations? Science historians have written entire books on this.

Some things we'd add: Does the experiment have a small sample size? Has the lead scientist committed scientific fraud in the past? Is the investigation predicated upon widely cited, but totally bunk, science?

Or you could just go with a great "Your Argument is Invalid" meme.

Morgan Freeman cotton candy your argument is invalid meme

You May Also Like: