Sign up FAST with Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn! Sign Up Login

Do athletes need squats?

I was blown away to read that former NY Giants and current 49ers running back Brandon Jacobs has never done squats to prepare for the NFL season.

Apparently neither has 49ers outside linebacker Ahmad Brooks for at least 2 years.

Don't these guys require lower-body explosiveness and drive? I was always taught that the squat was basically the foundational lift of all foundational lifts, and that it wasn't really possible to leave them out of a strength training routine.

3:40 PM Aug 09 2012

Props Given:
2

Squats is strength-related, explosiveness is more a function of fast-twitch muscles, which are usually developed through plyometric drills (e.g. Jump roping, box jumping). Running up hill, lunges, running with weighted vests would all be exercises that could provide similar strength without the adverse knee impact.

6:33 PM Aug 09 2012

Wait, squats are bad for the knees?

9:44 PM Aug 09 2012

Many people believe so. Essentially loading 300-500 lbs on shoulders, bending at the knees to sitting position and standing up. Long-term adverse side effect.

4:34 AM Aug 10 2012

What if you did smaller numbers like 100-150 lbs? Is the motion itself harmful?

8:47 AM Aug 10 2012

I think some believe it's like marathons; for elites and others who have constant medical attention, they may and will face no adverse side-effects. In fact, believe some say it's both the reputation and the stress.

4:12 PM Aug 10 2012

Olympic lifts > Squats.

Especially for explosiveness.

7:17 PM Aug 09 2012

Props Given:
2

By Olympic lifts are you referring to snatches, clean and presses, or clean and jerks?

http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/olympiclift.htm

9:45 PM Aug 09 2012

Yes. Eric is absolutely correct.

4:33 AM Aug 10 2012

I heard this a couple months ago stating that her research found squats were the best exercise - http://www.npr.org/2012/05/12/152494889/fresh-air-weekend-lena-dunham-gretchen-reynolds . Always something different.

9:02 AM Aug 10 2012

Props Given:
1

Thanks for reminding me where I heard that, too.

I think for anything fitness related we can find people who are pro and con.

9:40 AM Aug 11 2012

You May Also Like:

STASHES